GetVisa wrote:I think the conversation is changing its course from talking about my project to discussing why or why not kicktraq is good

Well, if it is a very narrow and focused conversation that you want, your initial question that you posed was: Do you think its a failure?
As worded, it seeks a yes or no answer. My response to that question is: No.
That doesn't give you much to work with, though. The devil is always in the details, where problems are concerned.
You want experts to advise you about your project's progress within the first 50 hours of a 31 day campaign, juxtaposed against the example that your mentioned, the one where you read somewhere.
Somewhere.
What can happen over the course of a 31 day crowd funding campaign? Quite a lot, actually. But, even then, it just depends upon wide range of different factors.
But, if what you are after is a yes or no answer, then my two cents on the subject would be a firm, "No."